Monday, January 12, 2009

By Any Means Necessary?

Civic debate seems to be turning ugly in America. After the pro-marriage Proposition 8 was passed in California, angry gay-rights activists vented their fury on Mormons and Christians, who publicly opposed marriage by homosexuals. Pro-life activists have long experienced social marginalization at the hands of pro-choice organizations and their sympathizers in the mainstream media, according to the final article by the late Richard John Neuhaus. And now Jews in the Chicago area are facing the wrath of vandals responding to Israel's Gaza invasion. "This touches a raw nerve," Rabbi Zvi Engel of Congregation Or Torah in Skokie said, responding to "Death to Israel!" slogans and other provocations on area synagogues. "You have to remember, in our congregations, there are people who remember this happening in Europe" at the start of the Holocaust. Even in America, where freedom of speech is enshrined as a core value, many seek to win debates in the public square by any means necessary.

2 Comments:

Blogger Ravan Asteris said...

You know, gays refusing to be treated as second class citizens is a far cry from anti-Semitism. Getting close to Godwin'ing yourself.

Tolerant does not mean doormat, you know.

5:06 PM  
Blogger Stan Guthrie said...

Ravan,

I don't know what your reference means, but vandalism, intimidation, and character assassination are far cries from simply standing up for what you believe should be proper public policy. Such a response to electoral defeat may not be anti-Semitism (though it could be anti-religious bigotry). But regardless, such tactics are ugly and illegal and do the gay-rights movement no favors.

Stan

9:20 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home